The Luquillo Critical Zone Observatory (LCZO) focuses on how water balances and mass fluxes differ in landscapes with contrasting lithology across a range of climatic and vegetation zones. Parent material has been recognized as a state factor for landscape and soil development for over a century. However, the influences of lithology on denudation, hydrologic routing, and the elemental cycles and flows is still poorly constrained in most studies. The LCZO will use the natural laboratory of the Luquillo Mountains to determine how critical zone processes differ in watersheds underlain by quartz diorite (GD ) and volcaniclastic (VC) bedrock (Figure 1). Specifically, the LCZO will address how the bedrock is coupled to or decoupled from the hydrologic, geochemical and biogeochemical cycles in these watersheds. A set of interrelated hypotheses (Figure 2, Table 1) will be tested taking advantage of the cohesive network of sampling sites (Table 2) and a unified data management system. This approach facilitates controlled comparisons across bedrock (GD, VC) types, landscape position (ridge, hillslope, riparian), depths (surface to bedrock), forest type (Tabonuco, Colorado, Cloud) and distance from the headwaters (upland to coastal).
Short term responses (e.g. days to seasons) to be investigated include the influence of lithology on biogeochemical responses to storms and droughts, and the influence of lithology on hydrologic routing and watershed hydrologic budgets. Recent research indicates there are greater seasonal variations in the chemistry of atmospheric inputs and soils processes than previously expected (Heartsill et al 2007, Shanley 2008, Scholl in press). These responses will be quantified using an improved network of weather stations, nested stream gages and multi-investigator event sampling campaigns. Responses at intermediate time scales (e.g. decades to centuries) will be evaluated by quantifying stream channel dynamics and examining the conditions in the past recorded in the sediments of the floodplains and coastal zones. The long-term influences of lithology on sediment generation, hillslope and landscape development will be evaluated in studies of bedrock weathering rates and rates of saprolite and soil formation.
Figure 2: Conceptual framework and relationships between the hypothesis and sampling nodes for the Luquillo Critical Zone Observatory. Infrastructure is in red while hypothesis are in green.
Hypothesis 1: The rate of saprolite advance varies with regolith thickness and landscape position and is fastest in GD valleys and slowest on VC ridges. Over large areas, the rate of saprolite advance will equal the rate of denudation and can be predicted from bedrock chemistry, porefluids, and physical rock properties (Brantley, Buss, White, Heimsath, Willenbring,).
The rate of saprolite production increases with regolith thickness, which depends on landscape position and bedrock type. The rates should be fastest in GD valleys and slowest on VC ridges. Over large areas, the rate of weathering will equal the rate of denudation resulting steady state landscape profiles. The magnitude of the rates can be predicted from bedrock chemistry, porefluids composition, and physical rock properties
Hypothesis 2: In surface soils, chemical transformations of atmospheric inputs are decoupled from bedrock lithology and influenced by soil carbon, surface redox, and plant nutrient cycling. Biotic influences on soil biogeochemistry decrease with storm intensity and soil depth and are greatest in surface soils of the VC during low intensity rainfalls (Johnson, Shanley, Silver, Scatena, UPR).
Hypothesis 3: The routing of water through the critical zone is determined by bedrock lithology. The residence time will be longer in areas underlain by GD and shorter in areas underlain by VC resulting in differences in water chemsitry. However these differences will decrease with storm intensity and duration (Scholl, Scatena, Shanley, McDowell).
Hypothesis 4: Over seasonal time scales, iron reduction and the associated CO2 production will vary across the landscape based on differences in soil redox and organic matter content. Iron reduction will be greatest in riparian VC surface soils and lowest at depth on stable GD ridge tops. At larger spatial scales and longer time scales deep weathering rates and iron cycling are closely linked to the frequency of low redox events and carbon availability (Silver, Brantley, Plante)
Hypothesis 5: The morphology and soil biogeochemistry of riparian and colluvial deposits varies systematically with lithology and distance from the headwaters. In contrast, the vegetation and soil organic matter chemistry vary systematically with rainfall and temperature (McDowell, Plante, Silver, Scatena, Jerolmack).
Hypothesis 6: Surface erosion is the dominant source of sediment to the stream channel network across the entire landscape. While surface erosion is associated with rainfalls of moderate intensity in VC watersheds, in the GD watersheds sediment originates from the landslides associated with high intensity precipitation events (Jerolmack, Horton, Willenbring, Scatena, Shanley).
Hypothesis 7: The temporal resolution of the climatic disturbances and land use change recorded in coastal and fluvial sediments differs between lithologies. The GD watersheds will have a higher resolution record than corresponding environments in the VC watersheds because of …(Horton, Willenbring, Jerolmack, Heimsath, Scatena).
13 Jul 2017 - Researchers at NSF Critical Zone Observatory and Long-Term Ecological Research sites are finding out.
21 Apr 2017 - AGU has published a collection of commentaries highlighting the important role Earth and space science research plays in society.
06 Apr 2017 - 2017 CZO Webinar Series: Critical Zone and Society.
10 May 2016 - A new study suggests suggest that the self-organization of bedrock river channels blunts the impact of extreme rainfall events.
23 Mar 2016 - PhD student, Global Institute for Water Security, University of Saskatchewan
15 Nov 2015 - Get a sense of the people and the work. Several members of the Luquillo CZO are profiled here, including students and professors.
22 Nov 2016 - CZOs at AGU 2016: Agenda and award recipients
27 Oct 2016 - A pioneering research project is aiming to determine how forests in the Amazon, the Congo and elsewhere in the tropics will reacting to rising tempera
13 Jul 2016 - National Science Foundation-funded research results presented at 2016 Ecological Society of America meeting in August
01 Jul 2016 - Using Puerto Rico's Luquillo Mountains as a case study, scientists use the region's geological history to study how knickpoints—areas...
09 Jun 2016 - PhD Student, Soil Science, University of Georgia
Growing new generations of critical zone scientists. Adam S. Wymore, Nicole R. West, Kate Maher, Pamela L. Sullivan, Adrian Harpold, Diana Karwan, Jill A. Marshall, Julia Perdrial, Daniella M. Rempe, Lin Ma (2017): Earth Surface Processes and Landforms Cross-CZO National
Geochemical evolution of the Critical Zone across variable time scales informs concentration-discharge relationships: Jemez River Basin Critical Zone Observatory. McIntosh J.C., Schaumberg C., Perdrial J., Harpold A., Vázquez-Ortega A., Rasmussen C., Vinson D., Zapata-Rios X., Brooks P.D., Meixner T., Pelletier J., Derry L., Chorover J. (2017): Water Resources Research 53(5): 4169–4196 Cross-CZO National
Controls on deep critical zone architecture: a historical review and four testable hypotheses. Riebe, C. S., Hahm, W. J., Brantley, S. L. (2017): Earth Surface Processes and Landforms, 42 (1): 128–156 Cross-CZO National
Special issue of The Earth Scientist about the Critical Zone and the US NSF Critical Zone Observatory (CZO) program. CZO Education/Outreach team (2016): The Earth Scientist, Volume XXXII, Issue 3, Fall 2016 Cross-CZO National
Variation of organic matter quantity and quality in streams at Critical Zone Observatory watersheds. Miller, Matthew P., Boyer, Elizabeth W., McKnight, Diane M., Brown, Michael G., Gabor, Rachel S., Hunsaker, Carolyn T., Iavorivska, Lidiia, Inamdar, Shreeram, Johnson, Dale W., Kaplan, Louis A., Lin, Henry, McDowell, William H., Perdrial, Julia N. (2016): Water Resources Research, 52 (10): 8202–8216 Cross-CZO
Reconstructing the transport history of pebbles on Mars. Szabó T., Domokos, G., Grotzinger, J.P., Jerolmack, D.J. (2015): Nature Communications
A field comparison of multiple techniques to quantify groundwater–surface-water interactions. González-Pinzón, R., Ward, A., Hatch, C., Wlostowski, A., Singha, K., Gooseff, M., Haggerty, R., Harvey, J., Cirpka, O., and Brock, J. (2015): Freshwater Science, 34(1) Cross-CZO
Analytical model for flow duration curves in seasonally dry climates. Müller, M.F., Dralle, D.N., and Thompson, S.E. (2014): Water Resources Research 50(7): 5510-5531. Cross-CZO
Rapid iron reduction rates are stimulated by high-amplitude redox fluctuations in a tropical forest soil. Ginn, Brian, Christof Meile, Jared Wilmoth, Yuanzhi Tang, and Aaron Thompson (2017): Environmental Science & Technology 51 (6): 3250-3259
Optimized high-throughput methods for quantifying iron biogeochemical dynamics in soil. Huang, W., Hall S.J. (2017): Geoderma
Reassessing rainfall in the Luquillo Mountains, Puerto Rico: Local and global ecohydrological implications. Murphy SF, Stallard RF, Scholl MA, González G, Torres-Sánchez AJ (2017): PLOS ONE
Weathering and erosion of fractured bedrock systems. Lebedeva M.I., Brantley S.L. (2017): Earth Surface Processes and Landforms
Extreme storms drive riverine particulate organic matter export from tropical mountians of estern Puerto Rico. Kathryn E. Clark, Robert F. Stallard, Martha A. Scholl, Alain F. Plante, Sheila F. Murphy, Grizelle Gonzalez, and William H. McDowell (2017): ...
Designing a network of critical zone observatories to explore the living skin of the terrestrial Earth. Brantley, S.L., McDowell, W.H., Dietrich, W.E., White, T.S., Kumar, P., Anderson, S., Chorover, J., Lohse, K.A., Bales, R.C., Richter, D., Grant, G., and Gaillardet, J. (2017): Earth Surface Dynamics Cross-CZO National
A method for quantifying cloud immersion in a tropical mountain forest using time-lapse photography. Bassiouni, M., Scholl, M.A., Torres-Sanchez, A.J., Murphy, S.F., (2017): Agricultural and Forest Meteorology